We ended up walking along Robson Street looking looking looking.
I finally stopped a woman and asked her what she would recommend. She said that White Tower has the best pizza ... so off we went.
I ordered the All Meat Pizza pizza (salami, sausage, bacon, and beef).
Sister Sarah ordered Vegetarian (mushrooms, green peppers, onion, olives, and tomatoes - she swapped the olives for pineapple).
They were okay, not great. But our craving for pizza is gone.